Five Handmade Engagement Rings Under $500
Sarah Richards
Updated on March 29, 2026
Today's ring finds are all from Etsy, and they get major Save the Date props for being unique, beautiful and affordable.
A rose gold ring with a teeny solitaire diamond
This dainty engagement ring with a .10 carat stone is nothing showy, but it sure is pretty. If you're not a rose gold person (I am—I love how warm it looks against my skin), the band can be customized in white or yellow gold too.
$295 from blancamonrosgomez at etsy.com
A raw-looking sapphire ring
Those looking to go the way of the not-diamond engagement bling will love this smoky-blue color sapphire in a hexagon-cut. The chunky setting says bold and modern while the stone screams originality.
$400 from onestonenewyork at etsy.com
